Home   Departments

Shelter Island Town Police

For emergencies call 911
 Non-emergencies call 631-749-0600
ALL power outages should be reported to PSEG at 1-800-490-0075
Click here for information on NYS Junior Driver's Licenses

click HERE for boat storage on town property instructions/guidelines

Click here for boat storage on town property application form



Free gun locks and gun safety information from Project ChildSafe are available at SIPD headquarters

Click HERE for more information on gun safety


  • Scammers are utilizing more advanced technology to make it more difficult to spot their deception.

  • Screening calls using caller ID may no longer work since scammers are using spoofing software which allows them to mimic the IDs of legitimate sources.

  • Neither government agencies nor utility companies will ask for payment in the form of prepaid gift cards.

  • Caution and skepticism are the best defenses. Visit a biller’s website to determine if you have any overdue bills.

  • Beware of e-mails that appear to be bills from a utility company that ask for personal information. This can lead to identity theft.

    CLICK HERE for more information


Click HERE for information on recent “Publishers Clearing House” scams.


Phone scammers posing as PSE&G employees are targeting customers on Shelter Island and across the nation.  These scammers are using false phone numbers that could appear on a caller ID to be PSE&G, and a recording of their customer service phone message is used to make them sound legitimate.  They then threaten to shut off service unless a payment is made immediately. 

Most often, scammers demand payment via a pre-paid credit card that can be purchased at a local store.  Sometimes they request payment to be made through a money transfer service such as Western Union or MoneyGram.  These calls are NOT from PSE&G.  PSE&G would never demand a specific type of payment or threaten immediate service termination. 

If a caller directs you to go to a local store to purchase pre-paid cards to pay your bill, it is likely a scam.  If you receive a strange call and are in doubt, hang up and call PSE&G on the number printed on your bill.


Some residents of Shelter Island and Suffolk County have reported being contacted by a person who claims to be a representative of the Internal Revenue Service (or other governmental agency.) The caller often claims their role with the IRS is a senior auditor or investigator. Generally, the caller starts off with a polite “suggestion” that the IRS has uncovered some discrepancies with your filings and that you owe the IRS money. If you do not initially cave to their scheme, the callers have a history of amping up the pressure, becoming more accusatory, and in some cases claiming that a warrant has been issued for your arrest and that agents are on their way to arrest you. DO NOT provide these individuals with ANY PERSONAL INFORMATION, BANKING INFORMATION, CREDIT/DEBIT CARDS NUMBERS OR SEND THEM MONEY VIA ELECTRONIC WIRE. If you get a call from someone claiming to be from the IRS, the IRS recommends the following:  

  • If you know or believe that you owe taxes, contact the IRS at 1-800-829-1040.

  • If you know that you do not owe taxes and believe that the call was a scam attempt, please call the Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration at 1-800-366-4484.

SIPD Mission Statement

The principal mission of the Shelter Island Town Police Department is to protect life and property, to work with our citizens to reduce crime, disorder and the fear of crime. 

Through community-oriented and problem solving policing the members of the Shelter Island Town Police Department will provide personalized services to the public with respect for human dignity according to the highest standards of professionalism, integrity and accountability. It is essential that all members remember that in the execution of our duties we act not for ourselves but for the good of the public. 


The Town of Shelter Island is located geographically between the north and south forks of eastern Long Island in Suffolk County, New York. Shelter Island is approximately five miles by five miles in size and also encompasses surrounding bodies of water such as Shelter Island Sound, and Gardiners Bay. 

The Shelter Island Town Police Department serves the community twenty-four hours a day, seven days a week.  Our agency is one of the most unique police agencies in New York State; there is no bridge to the island and our ferry-only access limits immediate assistance from associated agencies. The Shelter Island Police Department takes great pride in its preparedness. The Department has two major sections, patrol and investigative.  The patrol section handles all calls for service, preliminary investigations and maritime activities. The investigation section handles all investigative and criminal cases. 

Statistics 2018

In 2018 the Shelter Island Police responded to the following emergency and general calls for service for our citizens.  
Calls for Service - 3645 • Criminal Cases - 117 • Arrests - 61 • Tickets - 343
Town Summons - 25 • Aided Cases - 290 • Motor Vehicle Accidents (All) - 103 • Deer Related MVA - 36


NYS Accredited law enforcement agency

Shelter Island Town Police Department is an Accredited Law Enforcement Agency recognized by the New York State Law Enforcement Accreditation Council.